Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal Roofing: Which Is Better for Your Home?

Understanding the Basics

A roof’s job is simple—protect your home from the elements—but the way it does that varies by material. Asphalt shingles consist of fiberglass mats coated with asphalt and mineral granules and are laid in overlapping strips. Metal roofs are made of steel, aluminum, copper, or zinc panels or shingles that lock together and attach to the roof deck. Because metal expands and contracts, installers must pay careful attention to fastening techniques. Knowing these basics helps you appreciate why cost, longevity, and maintenance differ so much between the two.

Which Is Better, Metal Roof or Asphalt Shingles? A Cost Overview

When comparing Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal Roofing: Which Is Better for Your Home?, cost often comes first. Asphalt shingles are the most budget-friendly option, costing $1–$4 per square foot and about $6,000–$12,000 for a typical home. They’re quick to install, often in a day or two, and labor rates are lower. Metal roofs cost more because of higher material prices and specialized labor; depending on the type, they run $4–$30 per square foot. That means a 2,000‑square‑foot metal roof could range from $8,000 to $60,000, with basic corrugated metal at the low end and premium metals like copper at the high end. If you need a low‑cost Roof Replacement, asphalt shingles usually make sense; if you can invest more for long‑term value, metal may pay off. When comparing bids, be sure to discuss Roof Installation of other Roofing services. Understanding the full scope of labor and material costs will help you evaluate whether asphalt or metal fits your budget and long‑term goals. For a deeper dive into pricing, check out this roof cost guide from This Old House.

Lifespan, Durability, and Maintenance

Shingle roofs typically last 15–30 years depending on quality, installation, and climate. They can crack in extreme temperatures, absorb moisture, and develop moss, so they require periodic inspections, gutter cleaning, and occasional repairs. Metal roofs, by contrast, often last 40–70 years or more and resist rot, insects, and fire. Heavy hail or fallen branches may dent them, and installation errors can cause leaks, but maintenance is minimal—usually just annual checks and tightening fasteners. The long service life can reduce the number of Worthington Roof Installation projects you’ll need over decades.

What Is the Downside to a Metal Roof?

Despite their durability, metal roofs have drawbacks. The biggest is the upfront cost, which can be two or three times that of shingles. Because metal expands and contracts, installation must be precise; mistakes can lead to leaks or panels loosening. Without adequate insulation, rain and hail can sound louder on metal. Premium metals like copper and zinc add considerable weight, so your roof structure may need reinforcing by a professional Worthington Roofing Company. Cosmetic issues like oil canning (a wavy appearance) may also occur, though they don’t affect performance.

Energy Efficiency and Sustainability

For eco‑minded homeowners, metal roofs are compelling. Most are made from recycled materials and can be recycled again after decades of service. Their reflective surfaces lower cooling bills by 10–25%, and some products qualify for energy tax credits. Asphalt shingles, by comparison, are petroleum‑based and non‑recyclable; roughly 11 million tons of shingles are dumped into landfills each year. They absorb heat, which can raise indoor temperatures and energy costs. For a deeper look at why metal appeals to sustainability‑focused homeowners, check out Why Homeowners Choose Metal Roofing for Long‑Lasting Protection.

Appearance and Curb Appeal

A roof is a significant visual element, so aesthetics matter. Asphalt shingles offer the broadest palette of colors and textures. Three‑tab shingles provide a clean, uniform look; architectural shingles add depth and shadow lines; and luxury shingles mimic slate or wood shakes. Metal roofs evoke a modern vibe and come in standing seam panels, shingles, or tiles. Metals like copper age gracefully with a patina, while coated steel or aluminum offers durable color options. Your choice should complement your home’s style and neighborhood context.

Return on Investment and Resale Value

Both materials can boost your home’s value, but their return on investment (ROI) differs. Asphalt shingles typically yield around a 61% ROI—you might recover about $18,000 from a $30,000 roof when you sell. Metal roofs average about 49% ROI, roughly $23,000 on a $47,000 investment. Even though the percentage is lower, the dollar value recouped is similar because metal roofs cost more upfront. Prospective buyers often appreciate metal’s longevity and energy efficiency, which can make your home stand out.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Putting a Metal Roof Over Shingles?

Some homeowners install metal over old shingles to save on tear‑off costs and reduce waste. The benefits are lower labor costs and keeping shingles out of landfills, and the extra layer can improve insulation. However, adding metal increases weight and may require structural reinforcement. Uneven shingle surfaces can cause thin metal panels to look wavy, and some manufacturers’ warranties prohibit installation over shingles. Proper ventilation is essential to prevent moisture buildup. Before choosing this method, consult an experienced roofer and verify that local codes and product warranties allow it.

Making Your Decision: Asphalt vs Metal Roofing

So, Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal Roofing: Which Is Better for Your Home? It really depends on your priorities. Asphalt shingles win on upfront cost, ease of installation, and variety of styles. They’re ideal for homeowners on a budget, those planning to sell soon, or people who prefer a classic look. Metal roofing costs more but offers exceptional longevity, minimal maintenance, and superior energy efficiency. It’s a smart choice if you plan to stay in your home for decades or want a sustainable solution. Evaluate how long you intend to live in your home, your local climate, and how much upkeep you’re comfortable with. Then talk to a trusted Roof Replacement professional to compare options.

Pros and Cons at a Glance

CategoryMetal RoofAsphalt ShinglesLifespan40–70+ years15–30 yearsUpfront CostHigherLowerEnergy EfficiencyReflective and eco‑friendlyLess efficientMaintenanceMinimalRegular cleaning neededDurabilityResistant to rot, fire, insectsSusceptible to cracking and moistureStyle VarietyModerate to limitedExtensiveEase of RepairProfessional help often requiredIndividual shingles easy to replaceROI~49%~61%

Conclusion: Your Roof, Your Choice

Choosing between asphalt shingles and metal roofing isn’t a one‑size‑fits‑all decision. If cost, quick installation, and style options are your top concerns, asphalt shingles are likely your best bet. If you value durability, lower maintenance, and better energy performance, investing in metal roofing could be worthwhile. Speak with a knowledgeable Worthington Roofing Company for personalized advice and precise cost estimates. With informed guidance, you can select a roof that protects your home and matches your priorities for years to come.

‍