Do gutters have to be removed when replacing a roof?

Replacing your roof is a major project, and it’s natural to wonder about all the details – including what happens to your gutters. As a homeowner, you might ask yourself, do gutters have to be removed when replacing a roof? In many cases, the answer is no – you can often replace a roof without removing the gutters. Roofers regularly work around existing gutters by protecting them during the job. However, there are scenarios where taking gutters off makes the roofing process easier or prevents potential issues. We’ll explore both sides so you can make an informed decision. (If you’re not sure how old your current roof is, you can learn How to Find Out When My Roof Was Replaced in the Past to plan your project.)

Whether you keep your gutters on or remove them, a professional approach is key. If you’re planning a Roof Replacement, let’s dive into how roofers handle gutters and what factors to consider for your home.

Can you install a new roof without removing gutters?

Most of the time, yes – you can install a new roof without removing the gutters. Skilled roofing contractors have methods to work around your existing gutter system. Typically, they will cover the gutter runs with plywood or tarps to shield them from falling debris. They also avoid resting ladders or heavy tools directly on the gutters to prevent dents or bends. This means your roof replacement can proceed with gutters in place as long as those gutters aren’t in the way of critical work.

Working with the gutters attached does require some extra caution. During tear-off of old shingles, roofers must be careful that roofing materials don’t clog or damage the gutters. Many crews will use a heavy-duty blower or even manually clean the gutters after the roof is finished to ensure no debris is left inside. If the gutters are fairly new or in good shape, contractors prefer to leave them up. In short, removing gutters is not a routine part of roof replacement unless there’s a specific reason. You can get a brand new roof installed without taking down your gutters – and reputable roofers do this all the time.

Do roofers take gutters off when replacing a roof?

Generally, most roofers do not remove gutters when replacing a roof unless it’s absolutely necessary. If the homeowner isn’t planning on new gutters, contractors know it’s best to leave the gutter system intact. Removing and re-hanging gutters adds extra labor and can introduce risks of damage, so it’s avoided in a standard roof replacement. Instead, roofers focus on safeguarding the gutters on the house. They’ll refrain from leaning materials on them and might use special ladder standoffs (stabilizers that touch the wall instead of the gutter) to prevent pressure on the gutter edge.

That said, every project is unique. Roofers will take gutters off if needed to facilitate specific work. For example, if part of the job involves replacing rotten fascia boards (the wooden board behind the gutter), the gutters in that section must come down to access the fascia. In some cases, the way gutters are attached could interfere with roofing: if the gutters are mounted in a way that covers the roof’s edge or are screwed into the roof deck, removal might be required. But under normal circumstances, when gutters are attached to the fascia and not causing an obstruction, roofers keep them on. They understand that homeowners ask “Do gutters have to be removed when replacing a roof?” and the answer is usually no, not unless you are also replacing the gutters or repairing structures underneath them.

Reasons to Remove Gutters When Replacing a Roof

While not mandatory, there are a few good reasons to remove gutters during a roof replacement in certain situations. Removing the gutters can make the roofing process smoother or help address underlying issues. Here are some common reasons a homeowner or contractor might opt to take gutters off before installing a new roof:

• Easier access to roof edges: With gutters out of the way, roofers have unobstructed access to the eaves and roof perimeter. This makes it simpler to remove old shingles and install new roofing materials at the edges. They can lay underlayment and new shingles without working around a gutter’s lip. Components like drip edge flashing (which goes along the roof edge) are easier to put in place with no gutter blocking the space.
• Preventing gutter damage: Roof replacement is a messy job – old shingles and nails will be coming off, and contractors will be moving ladders and boards around. By temporarily removing the gutters, you eliminate the risk of heavy debris denting or scratching them. It also prevents accidents like a section of old roofing falling and pulling at the gutter. No gutter in place means no chance of damage during the construction.
• Fascia inspection and repair: Gutters attach to the fascia board running along your roof edge. Removing gutters allows the roofing crew to thoroughly inspect the condition of those boards. If there is any hidden rot, water damage, or pest infestation in the fascia, they can fix it while the roof is being replaced. This ensures a solid, healthy structure before gutters go back up.
• Ensuring proper alignment: Sometimes when working around existing gutters, the new roof’s edges might not line up perfectly with the gutter placement. By taking gutters down and reinstalling them after the roof is done, you can ensure the gutters align to the new roof’s pitch and overhang. This helps rainwater flow correctly into the gutter without gaps or overflow. Essentially, reinstalling gutters post-roof gives a better fit.
• Opportunity to upgrade old gutters: If your gutters are in poor condition or over 15–20 years old, a roof replacement project is an ideal time to replace them. Removing the old gutters up front makes installing new ones straightforward once the roof is finished. You’re already investing in a new roof — pairing it with new gutters means your home’s entire water-shedding system gets an upgrade together. This can save you from doing a separate gutter project a year or two later.

These reasons don’t apply to every situation, but they illustrate why gutters may need to be removed when replacing a roof. Essentially, if the gutters impede the roofing work, might get damaged, or are due for an upgrade, taking them off is the smart move.

Reasons to Keep Gutters On During Roof Replacement

On the flip side, there are plenty of reasons to leave your gutters on while the roof is replaced. If your gutters are in serviceable condition and not in the way, keeping them installed can be beneficial. Here are some key reasons not to remove gutters during a roof replacement:

• Saves time and money: Removing and reattaching gutters is extra work. By keeping gutters on, you avoid the labor costs associated with taking them down and installing them again. The overall project will likely be completed faster, since the crew can focus solely on roofing. For homeowners on a budget or tight schedule, skipping gutter removal is attractive.
• Avoid unnecessary risk: Well-functioning gutters can be left alone to prevent any chance of damage from handling. Older gutters or those made of weaker materials might get bent or warped if taken down and put back up. If there’s no compelling reason to remove them, it’s safer to leave them in place rather than risk damaging a perfectly good gutter system.
• Gutters not interfering with roofing: In most homes, gutters attach to the fascia and sit just below the roofline. They typically do not obstruct the actual roof replacement process. Roofers can strip off old shingles and install new ones above the gutter line. As long as they’re careful with tools and materials (which professionals are), there’s no technical need to uninstall the gutters.
• Recently installed gutters: If you’ve just invested in new gutters or they are only a few years old, you’ll want to keep them. There’s no reason to remove a nearly new gutter system if it’s working well. Quality gutters are built to withstand some abuse, so a professional roofer can work around them and then ensure they’re cleaned out at the end of the job.
• Roofers know how to protect them: A competent roofing company will have procedures to shield your gutters throughout the roof replacement. They might use wooden boards or guard devices in the gutter to catch debris. They’ll be cautious with ladder placement and distribute weight so as not to crush the gutters. Because these protection measures are effective, removing gutters is often unnecessary. In the end, you get a new roof and your original gutters emerge unscathed (and typically get a good cleaning before the crew leaves).

In summary, if your gutters are in good shape and you’re not looking to replace them now, you do not have to remove the gutters when replacing your roof. Professional roofers replace roofs every day with gutters left on the house. It’s a routine part of their work to ensure the gutters are preserved.

Can you install drip edge without removing gutters?

A drip edge is a metal flashing installed along the edges of your roof, and it plays a critical role in directing water into the gutters. The drip edge sits under the shingles and over the edge of the roof decking, with a small lip that hangs out, so water drips into the gutter instead of running down the fascia. Installing new drip edge is typically part of a roof replacement – and yes, it’s possible to install drip edge without removing the gutters. Experienced roofers can slide the drip edge metal between the roof deck and the gutter, securing it to the decking. They may need to gently loosen the top of the gutter or its brackets to create a little working room, but a full removal isn’t required.

However, it’s worth noting that having the gutters off can make drip edge installation easier. With no gutter in the way, the roofer can quickly nail in the drip edge and ensure it’s perfectly aligned. When gutters stay on, it can be a bit more challenging to maneuver the flashing pieces – but a skilled roofer does this regularly. They might install the drip edge at an angle and then bend it down into place over the gutter. The key is that the drip edge must extend down into or behind the gutter to function correctly. So, while you can absolutely add a drip edge with gutters still attached, it’s a delicate task. In some older homes that never had drip edge, roofers will make it work by carefully tucking the flashing in. If anything, this is another scenario where a roofer might prefer temporary gutter removal, but only if necessary. Most of the time, they’ll manage the drip edge installation just fine with your gutters staying put.

Should you replace gutters at the same time as your roof?

Homeowners often wonder if it’s best to do a gutter replacement simultaneously with a roof replacement. The answer really depends on the condition of your current gutters. Many people do choose to replace gutters when getting a new roof for convenience. If your gutter system is aging, leaky, or damaged, tackling both projects together can be efficient. You’ll save yourself the hassle of scheduling a separate gutter job later on, and the install team can ensure the new roof and new gutters are perfectly coordinated. For example, our team offers Gutter Installation services in conjunction with roofing, so we can seamlessly fit new gutters right after finishing your roof. This one-stop approach means one contractor handles everything, and you avoid any finger-pointing between separate roof and gutter companies if an issue arises down the line.

On the other hand, if your existing gutters are in excellent shape, there’s no rule that you must replace them with the roof. You can certainly keep them and perhaps just give them a tune-up (seal any minor leaks, freshen the fasteners, etc.). Just be aware that your gutters will likely need attention or replacement before your new roof wears out. Typical asphalt roofs last 20+ years, while gutters might last 20 years as well if high-quality – but often gutters fail sooner due to clogs, storms, or wear. It’s fine to delay gutter replacement if they’re fine now; just plan for that expense in the future.

If you do decide to do both at once, the best practice is to do the roof first, gutters second. During the roof replacement, the old gutters (if they’re coming off) can serve to catch debris and protect your siding. Once the new roof is complete, the crew (or a gutter specialist) will then install the new gutters so they fit the new roof edges perfectly. Adding gutters will increase the overall project cost – usually gutters are priced by the linear foot (for instance, standard aluminum gutters might run in the range of $10–$15 per foot including installation). But doing it all together could save you some labor costs and certainly saves you the coordination headache. Ultimately, it’s your call. Replacing gutters at the same time as the roof is convenient if your budget allows and your gutters are due for an upgrade. If not, you can absolutely stick with your current gutters and address them a few years later as a separate Gutter Replacement project.

Conclusion: Do gutters have to be removed when replacing a roof?

After weighing all the factors, here’s the bottom line: No, gutters do not have to be removed when replacing a roof in most standard cases. A quality roofer can replace your roof while leaving the gutter system intact and protected. Removing gutters during roof replacement is only necessary in special situations – like when you plan to replace the gutters anyway, when there’s hidden damage to address, or when gutters physically block the roofing work. For the average roof replacement with healthy gutters, you can expect the contractors to work around them expertly.

Always discuss the plan for your gutters with your roofing contractor beforehand. They’ll inspect your gutter condition and advise you on the best course of action. In our experience, we find that clear communication upfront prevents any surprises – whether that means “We’ll cover and keep your gutters on,” or “We recommend taking them down for this project.” By understanding the role of gutters in a roof replacement, you ensure your home’s drainage system continues to function well alongside that brand-new roof. In the end, the goal is a smooth roof installation and a home that’s fully protected from rain runoff. With an experienced roofing team, you’ll achieve exactly that – gutters on or off, they’ll make sure your roof and gutter system work in harmony for years to come.

‍