What are the top 10 Roofing Companies in Worthington, Ohio?

If you’re asking, “What are the top 10 Roofing Companies in Worthington, Ohio?”, a strong shortlist includes 614 Exteriors, Imperial Roofing and Contracting, Everguard Exterior LLC, BluSky Roofing, and AAA Roofing Co.. Also worth comparing are Right Way Roofing, Newman Roofing, LLC, Feazel, Muth & Company Roofing, and The Roof Detective. The right fit depends on whether you need a repair, complete replacement, storm restoration, or broader exterior work.

Worthington homeowners have plenty of choices, which makes comparing roofers more important. U.S. Census Bureau data puts Worthington’s 2020–2024 median household income at $127,382, and many homes in the area represent significant long-term investments. A roof contractor should be chosen with the same care.

What are the top 10 Roofing Companies in Worthington, Ohio?

For this list, we looked at local presence, residential roofing experience, public reputation, service range, industry credentials, longevity, and the ability to serve Worthington homeowners. The order is meant to help narrow the field rather than suggest that the same contractor is right for every project.

1. 614 Exteriors

Based in Worthington, 614 Exteriors handles roof installation, replacement, repairs, storm restoration, siding, gutters, and exterior painting. Owner Keith Staschke has more than 25 years of construction and roofing experience, and the company is an Atlas PRO+™ Diamond Level Contractor.

One thing I like about Keith’s approach is his willingness to talk about projects that did not go perfectly. After a small restoration project unexpectedly grew far beyond its original scope, the company learned the importance of staying within its strongest areas and knowing when a specialty contractor should take over.

Homeowners can learn more through the company’s Worthington Roofing Company page.

2. Imperial Roofing and Contracting

Imperial is another Worthington-based roofing contractor with a substantial local review history. Its services include roof inspections, replacements, repairs, storm restoration, emergency tarping, siding, and gutters.

The company may be particularly relevant for homeowners dealing with wind or hail damage because insurance-related restoration is a significant part of its work.

3. Everguard Exterior

Everguard Exterior is headquartered in Worthington and provides roofing alongside siding, gutters, windows, doors, decks, and other exterior improvements.

That wider scope can make it worth considering when a project extends beyond shingles. For example, storm damage may involve roofing, siding, fascia, and gutters at the same time.

4. BluSky Roofing

BluSky Roofing is another Worthington-area contractor offering roof inspections, repairs, maintenance, and replacements. Its services also extend into siding, gutters, insulation, and ventilation-related work.

That can be useful when a roofing problem is connected to attic airflow or energy-efficiency issues rather than simply damaged shingles.

5. AAA Roofing Co.

AAA Roofing has operated in the Worthington area for decades. Its services include roof replacement, repairs, gutters, and siding, with experience involving asphalt shingles as well as other roofing systems.

Its long local history is worth considering for homeowners who place significant value on working with an established Central Ohio contractor.

6. Right Way Roofing

Right Way Roofing operates from nearby Columbus and serves Worthington along with other Central Ohio communities. The company handles roof replacement, repairs, gutters, siding, and several related exterior services.

Its roofing work includes standard asphalt systems as well as projects involving older homes, layered roofing, decking problems, and more complicated roof conditions.

7. Newman Roofing

Newman Roofing has served Central Ohio since 1992 and works throughout communities including Worthington. Roofing, siding, gutters, storm repairs, and full replacements are among its primary services.

The company is particularly known for a structured installation process, communication, property protection, and post-project cleanup.

8. Feazel

Feazel has served Central Ohio since 1988 and offers roof repair, replacement, siding, windows, storm restoration, commercial roofing, and solar roofing options.

Its size and range of services make it one of the more established names serving Worthington, particularly for homeowners interested in comparing different roofing systems or exterior upgrades.

9. Muth & Company Roofing

Muth & Company Roofing has operated in Central Ohio since 1992. Beyond replacement and repair, the company works with gutters, attic insulation, ventilation, skylights, and related roofing issues.

Its emphasis on ventilation is important. A roof can look fine from outside while poor attic airflow contributes to moisture, condensation, or ice-related problems underneath.

10. The Roof Detective

The Roof Detective serves Worthington from nearby Columbus and performs residential roof replacement, repair, maintenance, storm work, gutters, siding, and commercial roofing.

Its repair capabilities may make it worth comparing when you are not sure a complete roof replacement is actually necessary.

What should you compare before choosing a Worthington roofer?

Price matters, but scope matters more. Two estimates that appear thousands of dollars apart may include different shingles, underlayment, flashing, ventilation work, decking allowances, warranties, or cleanup procedures.

Keith from 614 Exteriors described tearing into roofs and occasionally discovering that far more plywood was damaged than anyone could see beforehand. An experienced roofing company should have a process for explaining those discoveries, pricing additional work, and getting materials to the site without turning the project into chaos.

The Ohio Attorney General’s home improvement guidance recommends checking references, insurance and bonding, obtaining multiple written estimates, and getting project promises in writing before hiring a contractor.

What is the 25% rule for roofing?

The “25% rule” is sometimes used online when discussing situations where extensive roof damage can affect whether repair or replacement makes sense. However, homeowners should not assume there is a blanket Ohio rule saying that damage to 25% of a roof automatically requires replacing the entire roof.

Building-code requirements, insurance coverage, manufacturer requirements, and local rules can differ. Have the damaged area documented and ask both your contractor and insurer what specifically applies to your property.

Is Worthington, Ohio a wealthy area?

Worthington has household income levels well above many communities in Ohio. Census data shows a median household income of $127,382 for 2020–2024, along with per-capita income of $70,806.

That does not mean every Worthington homeowner has an unlimited renovation budget. It does help explain why quality, longevity, curb appeal, and protecting home value can carry considerable weight when homeowners compare roofing systems.

Who is the best roofing company in Central Ohio?

There is no single roofing contractor that will be the best choice for every Central Ohio homeowner. A small leak, historic home, insurance restoration, metal roof, commercial building, and complete exterior renovation can each require different expertise.

For a Worthington homeowner specifically, 614 Exteriors is a strong local option because its headquarters are in Worthington and roofing is one of its primary services. Its team also handles Roof Installation in Worthington and Roof Repair in Worthington.

For a wider comparison, see Top 10 Roofing Companies in Columbus, Ohio​.

What is the average cost of a new roof in Ohio?

Roof prices vary considerably by roof size, pitch, materials, decking condition, ventilation, tear-off requirements, and the number of penetrations or architectural features.

For nearby Columbus, 2026 cost data from Angi puts an average roof replacement around $9,068, with many projects falling between roughly $5,688 and $12,760. Another Columbus estimate puts shingle projects around $7,163 to $22,920, illustrating how quickly the range changes once roof size and specifications are considered.

Get an actual roof measurement before relying too heavily on cost-per-square-foot estimates.

Should a 20 year old roof be replaced?

Not automatically. A 20-year-old asphalt roof deserves a careful inspection, but condition matters more than the birthday alone.

Look for widespread granule loss, curling or cracked shingles, recurring leaks, deteriorated flashing, soft decking, missing shingles, and ventilation problems. Keith has pointed out that contractors sometimes cannot fully assess decking until old roofing layers come off. That is why inspection and documentation matter before assuming either a simple repair or complete replacement is necessary.

Local experience matters after Ohio storms

Storms tend to bring an influx of contractors into affected communities. That makes vetting especially important.

Keith’s advice to homeowners is simple: research a company before allowing someone who unexpectedly arrives at your door onto the roof. Ohio’s Attorney General has issued similar warnings about storm-chasing contractors and recommends researching the business, obtaining written estimates, checking references, and avoiding large upfront payments.

A good roof is important. Having a company that will still answer the phone if something needs attention later may be just as important.

Choosing among the top Worthington roofing companies

When comparing the top 10 Roofing Companies in Worthington, Ohio, look beyond the sales presentation. Compare the actual roofing system, written scope, warranty, decking policy, ventilation approach, cleanup process, insurance coverage, local reputation, and what happens when unexpected problems appear.

Construction does not always go perfectly. Keith’s experience at 614 Exteriors reinforces a useful point: the real test of a contractor is often how the company responds when conditions change. Ask detailed questions, compare several written estimates, and choose the roofer whose process makes sense for your home—not simply the company with the lowest number at the bottom of the page.

‍